Order of the Eastern Star Lapel Pins

This item features a pair of small, multi-colored star-shaped pins housed within a black, hinged presentation box lined with black fabric and textured trim. The pins are designed with five distinct points, each showcasing alternating colored enamel sections in red, blue, yellow, green, and white, which are characteristic of fraternal organization insignia. At the center of each star is a smaller inverted pentagon shape containing microscopic lettering or symbols. The metal components appear to have a gold-toned finish, though the exact metal composition cannot be visually verified from the photograph alone. The owner provides a user-supplied attribution claiming the items are made of 14k gold, but this claim remains entirely unverified by physical testing, hallmark inspection, or documentation. The condition of the pins appears generally clean with intact enamel work, though minor wear and dust can be observed on the surrounding display case. There are no clearly legible maker's marks, stamps, or hallmarks visible in the image to confirm the manufacturer or precise metal purity. Stylistically, the items are consistent with standard fraternal lapel or collar pins associated with the Order of the Eastern Star, likely produced during the mid-to-late 20th century, but without clear hallmarks, this age and attribution remain unverified hypotheses based solely on visual design motifs.

Based on the photograph provided, I have evaluated this pair of multi-colored star-shaped pins housed in a presentation box, styled consistently with fraternal organization insignia such as the Order of the Eastern Star. Based on what I can see, the pins feature five-pointed stars with alternating enamel sections in red, blue, yellow, green, and white, alongside gold-toned metal components. However, I cannot verify the exact metal composition, manufacturer, or precise age from a photo alone, and I would need physical inspection and hallmark verification to confirm these details. Per user submission: the owner claims the items are made of 14k gold. This appraisal estimate assumes the owner's claim regarding the 14k gold composition is correct. Under that working assumption, comparable fraternal insignia of this type typically trade within a modest collector market range of $150 to $300, influenced by the intact enamel work and the inclusion of the original presentation box. If physical testing reveals the metal is gold-plated or base metal rather than solid 14k gold, the value would decrease significantly, likely falling into the $40-$75 range. To establish the actual value and ensure correct attribution, further steps would be needed, including in-person examination by a qualified jeweler, hallmark inspection, and precious metal acid or XRF testing.