Order of the Eastern Star Lapel Pins

This image presents a pair of small, multi-colored star-shaped pins resting inside a black hinged presentation box with a black velvet-textured insert and metallic gold-toned trim along the edges. The pins are designed as five-pointed stars, each featuring alternating colored enamel points in blue, yellow, white, green, and red, consistent with traditional fraternal iconography. At the center of each star is a small white pentagon or inverted triangle element containing subtle lettering or symbols. The metal backing appears to have a polished gold-tone finish, though precise hallmarks or metal purity stamps are not clearly legible from this photographic angle alone. The items are presented in a clean condition with no immediately visible structural damage to the enamel or metal structure. The owner provides user-supplied context suggesting these items are composed of 14k gold, though this claim remains completely unverified by physical testing or macro-examination of potential stamps. The identification of the items as Order of the Eastern Star insignia rests on the distinctive inverted five-colored star geometry and central symbolism. No maker's mark is visible in the frame, and the style suggests mid-to-late 20th-century fraternal regalia manufacturing, though exact age cannot be definitively established without closer inspection.

Based on what I can see in the photograph, this pair of small, multi-colored star-shaped pins resembles traditional Order of the Eastern Star fraternal insignia, featuring five-pointed stars with alternating enamel colors and a presentation box. However, I can't verify from a photo whether the metal is genuinely 14k gold as suggested in the user submission, nor can I read any potential hallmarks or assess the metal purity. The owner identifies this as 14k, and my estimate assumes this unverified claim is correct for the sake of valuation. Fraternal regalia and organizational lapel pins of this type typically trade in a modest collector market, where demand is largely driven by niche collectors of fraternal memorabilia. If the items are indeed constructed of 14k gold, the precious metal content forms a baseline for the value estimate, augmented by the collectible nature of the insignia. If the attribution or metal purity is incorrect—meaning the pins turn out to be gold-plated base metal, modern reproductions, or simply 'in the style of' vintage fraternal items—the market value would drop significantly, likely falling into the $30-$60 range based strictly on decorative value. To confirm authenticity, metal composition, and age, an in-person examination, professional hallmark verification, and possible acid or XRF testing by a qualified specialist would be required. Without physical inspection, this appraisal remains provisional.