Archival Document Appraisal

1917 Legal Correspondence from McInnes, Mellish, Fulton & Kenny

This item is an aged legal letter, typed on a piece of paper that appears to be off-white or cream-colored, suggesting its age. The paper exhibits significant signs of wear, including multiple creases and folds, particularly noticeable across the middle and top, which have resulted in discoloration and potential weakening of the paper fibers. The surface has a slightly mottled appearance, indicative of age and handling, with some areas appearing darker or lighter due to subtle staining or fading. The text is typed in a clear, consistent font, characteristic of early 20th-century typewriters. The letterhead at the top left reads "Mcnnes, Mellish, Fulton & Kenny Barristers, Solicitors, &C.," indicating the law firm that drafted the document. Below this, there are names of individuals, likely partners in the firm. On the top right, another header mentions "Halifax, N.S.," confirming the location, and the specific date "January 16th, 1917." The content of the letter addresses a legal matter, specifically referencing a case "Robinson vs. Green" and discussing an appeal. It cites a previous case, "Cooper vs. Blacklook, 5 Ontario Appeal Reports, page 535," and a judgment by Chief Justice Moss. The letter is addressed to "Dear Judge-" and concludes with "Yours respectfully," followed by an illegible handwritten signature, presumably of one of the solicitors. Below the closing, the recipient is named as "The Honorable Mr. Justice Russell," with an address "11 Inglis St., Halifax." This detail helps to identify the recipient and the local context. The overall condition suggests that the document has been stored, possibly folded, for many years, leading to the visible creasing and slight darkening of the paper, consistent with natural aging processes. There are no obvious tears or repairs, but the document is brittle in appearance. The ink from the typewritten text remains largely clear, though some faintness may be observed in certain areas due to paper degradation or light exposure. This document is a direct insight into early 20th-century legal proceedings and practices in Halifax, Nova Scotia, offering historical value.