AI Appraisal Estimate

This is a multi-piece, three-tier convention badge made for a delegate attending the New York State Firemen's Association gathering. The item is constructed from a die-struck base metal, likely a bronze or brass alloy with an antiqued silver-tone or nickel plating. The top header is shaped with scrollwork and features the text 'NEW YORK STATE FIREMEN'S ASSOCIATION' surrounding a central relief of a firefighter holding a nozzle. Below the header, suspended by short metal chains, is a rectangular nameplate bar embossed with the word 'DELEGATE'. The lowest section is a heavy oval medallion depicting a high-relief scene of Genesee Falls in Rochester, N.Y., which was the host location for the convention. The medallion also contains a smaller circular inset at the top showing a seal or emblem and is inscribed 'ROCHESTER, N.Y.' and 'GENESEE FALLS' along the bottom curve. The badge dates to August 1912 as indicated by the faint dating on the header section. Physically, the piece shows a significant dark patina and some wear to the plated finish, revealing the warmer-toned base metal beneath, particularly on high-relief points. The craftsmanship is typical of early 20th-century fraternal and commemorative medals, featuring intricate die-work and a sturdy chain-link assembly. No major structural damage like bends or breaks is visible, though the original mounting pin or ribbon that might have sat behind the top bar appears to be missing or obscured.

I have examined the provided images of the 1912 New York State Firemen's Association Delegate Convention Badge from the Rochester, N.Y. meeting. This three-tiered medal is a genuine representative of early 20th-century fraternal commemorative work. The die-struck relief showing Genesee Falls is particularly sharp, though the piece exhibits significant 'high-point' wear where the plating has rubbed away to reveal the brass/bronze substrate. The dark oxidation is consistent with an original 112-year-old patina. Market demand for early NYS firefighting memorabilia remains steady among local history collectors and fire service veterans. This specific badge is more desirable than generic member pins due to the 'Delegate' bar and the Rochester-specific iconography. However, the value is tempered by the apparent loss of the original silk ribbon, which typically sat between the bars. Comparables of intact multi-part NYSFA badges from this era generally realize between $100 and $225 at specialized auctions. Visual inspection suggests authenticity based on the crispness of the die-work and natural wear patterns. However, full authentication would require an in-person examination to verify the metallurgical composition via XRF testing and a check for modern lead-soldering repairs. Provenance documentation, such as the original delegate's name or association records, would further enhance the value. Without physical handling, I cannot confirm the functionality of the rear pin assembly or detect microscopic surface cleaning that may affect long-term preservation.