AI Appraisal Estimate

This is a metallic lapel pin or commemorative medallion designed to replicate the 1989-1990 Federal Migratory Bird Hunting and Conservation Stamp (Federal Duck Stamp). The item is rectangular with scalloped edges mimicking the perforations of a postage stamp. It features a bas-relief engraving of the artwork originally design by Neal R. Anderson, depicting two Lesser Scaup ducks in flight over a marshy landscape. The item is finished in a polished gold-tone metal, likely gold-plated brass or enamel-less cloisonné. Text on the pin includes '$12.50', 'U.S. DEPARTMENT OF THE INTERIOR', and 'MIGRATORY BIRD HUNTING AND CONSERVATION STAMP'. The phrase 'VOID AFTER JUNE 30, 1990' is also visible in small lettering. The condition appears fair to good; there are visible surface scratches on the high-polish border and some dark oxidation or tarnish settling into the recessed areas of the engraving. These pins were popular collectibles during the late 1980s and early 1990s as accessory pieces for outdoorsmen and conservationists. The level of detail in the casting is high, showing distinct feather textures on the ducks and reeds in the background scenery.

I have carefully examined the provided images of the 1989-1990 Federal Duck Stamp lapel pin, featuring Neal R. Anderson’s 'Lesser Scaup' design. The construction is a standard die-struck metal with a gold-tone finish. Based on visual inspection, I rate the condition as 'Fair to Good.' There is significant surface scratching on the polished borders and noticeable oxidation or 'pitting' within the recessed lettering and background textures. This indicates the item was likely worn or stored without a protective case. Market analysis shows that Duck Stamp memorabilia was produced in high volumes during the late 20th century to satisfy the demand of conservationists and philatelists. While the original stamps and certain limited-edition prints maintain value, these mass-produced metallic pins were widely distributed. Similar examples for the 1989-1990 year frequently appear on secondary markets (eBay, sporting auctions) at price points between $8 and $20 depending on the presence of the original display card. The item's value is primarily sentimental or as a 'filler' piece for a complete annual collection. The visible tarnish slightly hinders its appeal to premium collectors. Authenticity is assumed based on the characteristic casting of the period, but a physical inspection would be required to determine if the base metal is brass or a cheaper alloy, and if the gold finish is electroplated or simple lacquer. Furthermore, I cannot verify the integrity of the clasp mechanism from the frontal image. For a definitive valuation, I would need to observe the maker's marks on the reverse and confirm the lack of lead-based alloys through metallurgical testing, though such costs would exceed the item's market value.