AI Appraisal Estimate

This is a circular sterling silver presentation plate or trophy dish, manufactured by Revere Silversmiths Inc. and weighing approximately 60 grams. The plate features a wide, flat rim and a central depression where a commemorative engraving is located. At the center is a small, applied enameled burgee or pennant flag displaying horizontal blue and white stripes, representing the Larchmont Yacht Club. Below the enameled icon, the sterling silver is hand-engraved with the inscription: 'LARCHMONT YACHT CLUB / NATIONAL CHAMPIONSHIP SERIES / 5.5 METER CLASS / 9-16-57 / 1ST'. The fabrication indicates mid-20th-century craftsmanship, specifically dated 1957. The surface shows significant condition issues, including heavy tarnish, oxidation, and surface scratches consistent with its age. There are visible areas of 'fire scale' or dark pitting on the rim and several linear scratches across the center, likely from cleaning or handling. The reverse side, as noted in the provided context, is stamped 'REVERE SILVERSMITHS INC' and '901 STERLING'. This piece serves as a historical record of the 5.5 Meter Class sailing national championship, showcasing the intersection of sporting history and fine silver production.

Based on my examination of the submitted documentation and photographs, I have evaluated this sterling silver nautically-themed presentation piece. The item is hallmarks for Revere Silversmiths Inc. and is stamped '901 STERLING', confirming its material composition. Despite the 60g weight—which carries a modest intrinsic bullion value—the primary value lies in its provenance as a 1957 First Place trophy for the Larchmont Yacht Club's 5.5 Meter Class National Championship. This specific racing class was prominent in Olympic competition during that era, enhancing its historical appeal to sailing collectors. Condition is a significant factor: I observed heavy tarnish, oxidation, and prominent scratches. While many of these are superficial, the potential for 'fire scale' or deep pitting may require professional restoration, which has been factored into the valuation. The enameled burgee appears intact, which is critical for maintaining its specific associative value. In the current market, maritime memorabilia from elite yacht clubs remains in steady demand. Comparable pieces from high-prestige clubs like Larchmont typically command a premium over generic trophy silver. Limitation Disclosure: My assessment is based solely on provided images. A definitive valuation would require an in-person physical inspection to confirm the exact weight, check for structural repairs, and verify the enamel integrity. Comprehensive authentication would involve reviewing the Larchmont Yacht Club's historical archives to match the recipient of the 1957 5.5 Meter title, providing the necessary provenance to reach the high end of the estimated value range.