AI Appraisal Estimate

This item is a commemorative card or poster, likely oversized given the context, celebrating Dan Marino's achievement of becoming the 'All-Time Touchdown Pass Leader' with 343 touchdown passes. The item features a prominent photograph of Dan Marino in his Miami Dolphins uniform, wearing number 13 on a white jersey with green and orange accents, and a teal helmet with a white and orange stripe. The image appears to show Marino from the chest up, mid-action, possibly after throwing a pass. A gold-colored autograph, presumably Marino's, is visible across the lower left portion of his jersey. In the lower right corner, there's a distinct graphic designed to resemble a postage stamp, which reads '343 DAN MARINO ALL TIME TOUCHDOWN PASS LEADER'. Below this, the date 'November 26, 1995' is printed, indicating the date of the record-breaking event. The Upper Deck logo is also visible, confirming the manufacturer and an estimated age of 1995. The entire piece is encased in what appears to be a protective plastic sleeve or top-loader, consistent with how valuable sports memorabilia is typically preserved. The edges of this plastic casing appear slightly discolored or yellowed, suggesting some age or exposure to light, but the card itself appears to be in good condition without significant visible creases or tears. The materials are likely high-quality cardstock or photographic paper for the image, and a clear, rigid plastic for the protective sleeve. The craftsmanship indicates a mass-produced, officially licensed sports collectible, yet the autograph elevates its uniqueness and value. This piece is a significant collectible for football enthusiasts, particularly fans of Dan Marino or the Miami Dolphins.

Based on my examination of the provided image, this 1995 Upper Deck Dan Marino Commemorative Card, celebrating his 'All-Time Touchdown Pass Leader' achievement, appears to be in excellent condition. The card itself shows no obvious creases, tears, or significant surface imperfections. The protective plastic sleeve, though slightly yellowed, has preserved the card well. The prominent gold-colored autograph, presumably Dan Marino’s, significantly enhances its value. The Upper Deck branding and commemorative nature of the card indicate it is an officially licensed product from 1995. Market conditions for autographed vintage sports memorabilia, particularly from Hall of Fame quarterbacks like Marino, remain strong. Comparable sales of similarly autographed commemorative cards or larger format pieces from this era often fall into the mid-hundreds. Demand for Marino's signed items is consistent among Dolphins fans and football collectors. Rarity is moderate; while the card itself was mass-produced, a legitimate, authenticated autograph makes it less common. Key factors impacting value include the authenticity of the autograph and the card's overall condition. Without in-person examination, it's impossible to definitively confirm the autograph's authenticity. I'd typically look for consistency in penmanship, ink type, and pressure, and compare it against known exemplars. For full authentication, I would require an in-person examination by a reputable third-party authenticator (e.g., PSA/DNA, JSA) to verify the autograph's legitimacy. Additionally, assessing the exact grade of the card (corners, edges, centering, surface) would require physical inspection. Assuming the autograph is authentic, an appraisal value of $350 - $600 is appropriate, with a higher end for a card with professional authentication and a Gem-Mint or Near-Mint grade.