AI identification & appraisal estimate

Trading card encapsulated in a third-party grading slab, bearing markings consistent with a 2005 Upper Deck Legends Joe Montana card

Submitted photo of Trading card encapsulated in a third-party grading slab, bearing markings consistent with a 2005 Upper Deck Legends Joe Montana card
Photo submitted by the user — not generated by AI

User's notes

Signed Montana trading card certified

These notes were written by the person who submitted this item. Appraiser.AI has not verified them, and the AI's identification and estimate may rely on them.

AI Estimated Value

Not an official valuation

$150-$300

AI estimate as of July 31, 2026 · verify with a professional before acting

AI-Generated · Verify before acting

Everything on this page is generated by AI for informational purposes only. AI can make mistakes — the AI may misidentify items or misattribute them (artist, maker, brand, designer, origin, era). This is not an official valuation and should not be used for insurance, sale, tax, estate, legal, or lending purposes — or any decision requiring a certified appraisal. It is not an authoritative claim about any person, brand, or rights holder — do not share or rely on it as a factual statement about a third party. Always consult qualified professionals before making financial decisions.

This analysis also relies on unverified notes provided by the user, which may be incomplete or inaccurate and could affect the result.

Read the full disclaimer

AI Item Analysis

The item presented in the photograph is a sports trading card encased in a clear rectangular plastic grading slab. The card and slab display several visible printed texts and markings. The top label inside the slab reads "PSA/DNA", followed by the text "2005 UPPER DECK LEGENDS #95", "JOE MONTANA AUTHENTIC", and "PSA/DNA CERTIFIED AUTO", alongside a barcode and certification number "83179483". The card itself features a football player in a red and gold uniform resembling a San Francisco 49ers kit, holding a football, set against a blurred background with a border of small stars. The upper right corner of the card features an "UPPER DECK" logo. The bottom portion of the card includes a circular insert displaying a portrait and the name "JOE MONTANA", with "49ERS" on the left and "QUARTERBACK" on the right. Across the lower middle section of the card, there is a dark blue handwritten signature. The plastic slab appears to be in generally good condition with standard surface reflections and minor wear typical of storage. The owner's notes claim this is a signed Montana trading card that has been certified; however, this user-supplied attribution and the grading company slab itself are unverified from this photograph alone, as third-party holders and markings can theoretically be replicated or require physical inspection to establish validity. Hedged language is used in the title because visual identification from a photograph cannot serve as absolute proof of the card's physical composition or the absolute legitimacy of the encased signature and grading label without in-person examination by an expert.

AI Appraisal Report

Based on what I can see in the photograph, the item is a trading card encased in a plastic slab bearing markings and a label that reference a 2005 Upper Deck Legends Joe Montana card alongside a signature. Per user submission: attributed to a certified signed sports trading card. However, I cannot verify from a photo alone the physical composition of the card, the legitimacy of the encased signature, or the integrity of the third-party grading slab and certification number, as these holders and labels can theoretically be replicated and require physical inspection to establish validity. Assuming the working hypothesis that the markings and attribution are correct, comparable autographed trading cards of legendary quarterbacks from similar mid-2000s releases generally trade within the $150 to $300 range, depending on condition and market demand. Demand for iconic football memorabilia remains steady among collectors. If physical inspection reveals this piece to be a reproduction, replica, copy, or otherwise unattributed, the market value would drop significantly, likely falling to under $20. To confirm authenticity and the true nature of this piece, an in-person examination by a professional sports memorabilia expert and physical verification of the slab and autograph are required.

Keep exploring

More sports memorabilia appraisals

Get your items appraised

Instant AI-powered appraisal estimates from a photo

Browse More Appraisals