AI Appraisal Estimate

This is a modern collegiate sports trading card featuring Pat Tillman in his Arizona State University (Sun Devils) uniform. The card is a Parallel variant from the Panini Prizm Draft Picks series, specifically featuring the 'Orange Ice' cracked ice pattern. The card features a vibrant orange border with a geometric, holographic 'cracked ice' refractor finish that reflects light in multi-colored shards. Central to the design is an action photograph of Tillman in a white jersey with the number 42, wearing a gold helmet. The Panini Prizm logo is visible at the top center, and Tillman's name is printed at the bottom. The card appears to be in an upright, clear protective magnetic 'one-touch' hard case, which is itself placed on a clear display stand. The craftsmanship is typical of high-end modern chromium cards, utilizing layered plastic and metallic foils. Based on the design, this is likely from a set released between 2020 and 2023. The condition appears to be excellent with sharp corners and clean edges visible through the case, though light refraction on the plastic makes a definitive surface grade difficult without physical inspection. There are no obvious signs of fading, chipping, or moisture damage.

I have conducted a visual examination of the Pat Tillman Panini Prizm Draft Picks Orange Ice Parallel. The card is housed in a magnetic 'one-touch' holder, suggesting it has been handled with care. The centering appears well-balanced for the Prizm series, and the 'Orange Ice' cracked ice refractor finish displays the correct vibrance and geometric refraction patterns associated with genuine Panini chromium technology. The corners and edges appear sharp and free of the white chipping commonly found on these thicker stocks. Pat Tillman remains an iconic figure in sports and American history, maintaining a steady 'player floor' in the secondary market. As a collegiate licensed product rather than an NFL-shield card, the value is slightly more conservative compared to his professional-period relics; however, the Orange Ice parallel is a popular 'SSP' (Short Print) or case-hit equivalent in retail configurations, driving demand among ASU alumni and military tribute collectors. Comparable sales for unmapped Prizm Draft parallels of high-profile legends typically range between $30 and $90 depending on the current military holiday cycle or ASU football performance. This value assumes a Gem Mint (PSA 10) potential, though the current raw state commands the $40-$75 range. Limitations: This appraisal is based solely on digital imagery. A physical inspection is required to identify surface scratches, dimples, or 'doctoring' (such as trimmed edges) that are invisible under refractive light. Full authentication would require verified provenance or submission to a third-party grading service like PSA or BGS to confirm the card's integrity and provide a definitive numeric grade.