AI Appraisal Estimate

This is a Donruss brand 'Rated Rookie' football trading card featuring tight end Colston Loveland. The card displays standard modern trading card dimensions, approximately 2.5 by 3.5 inches, constructed from semi-glossy cardstock. The design features a white border surrounding a multi-layered blue and teal frame that houses a central action photograph of Loveland in a navy blue and white football uniform, holding a football. The player is depicted with a matte finish that contrasts slightly against the field background. Notable markings include the Donruss 'D' logo in the upper right, the 'Rated Rookie' blue banner in the bottom left, and the Chicago Bears 'C' logo in the bottom right corner. The text at the top identifies the player as 'COLSTON LOVELAND • TE'. The card appears to be in excellent condition, housed within a clear protective plastic sleeve and displayed on a stand. Centering seems well-aligned horizontally, though the bottom border appears slightly thicker than the top. No visible surface scratches, corner softening, or edge chipping can be seen through the protective layer, suggesting a near-mint status. This card represents a modern 'fantasy' or custom-style rookie card creation, as Colston Loveland is a collegiate player and the uniform features professional team markings, typical of recent unlicensed or custom artistic sports memorabilia.

I have carefully examined the provided images of this Colston Loveland 'Rated Rookie' style card. Based on my visual inspection, the item presents in Near Mint-Mint condition with sharp corners, clean edges, and strong surface gloss. While the horizontal centering is excellent, there is a slight vertical bias toward the bottom edge. This card is identified as a custom or 'art card,' as Colston Loveland is currently a collegiate athlete and this specific design—a Donruss 'Rated Rookie' template featuring a Chicago Bears logo—is not an official release from Panini America. Because this is an unlicensed custom creation rather than an official pack-pulled rookie card, its value is driven by 'fan art' demand rather than the standard sports card secondary market. Comparables for high-quality custom cards of popular collegiate prospects typically fall in the $15 to $35 range. The primary value driver is the player's current performance and the aesthetic quality of the custom design. However, as an appraiser, I must note that visual inspection alone cannot confirm the printing technology used or the quality of the cardstock. A full authentication would require an in-person examination to verify the ink density and potential copyright permissions. Without official licensing or third-party grading (which most services do not provide for custom cards), the market for this item is limited to niche collectors of collegiate memorabilia and custom art.