AI Appraisal Estimate

This is a vintage Crosby Prix St. George dressage saddle dating to the late 1980s, featuring a 17.5-inch seat and a medium tree. The saddle displays a sophisticated two-tone aesthetic, with a rich dark Havana brown leather seat and pommel contrasting against deep black leather flaps and skirts. It is constructed from high-quality, fine-grained leather, characteristic of the English craftsmanship Crosby was known for during this era. The saddle features a deep seat, long straight flaps typical of the dressage discipline, and distinct gold-tone metal hardware including a small circular maker's nail at the pommel. It is shown equipped with black leather stirrup leathers and stainless steel Fillis-style stirrup irons with white rubber pads. The condition appears exceptionally well-maintained for its age; the leather shows a supple patina with minimal cracking or 'crazing' seen on the flaps, and the stitching remains tight and intact. Notable features include the elegant light-colored piping along the seat edge and the padded knee rolls beneath the flap. This model is highly regarded for its close-contact feel and classic minimalist design, free of the oversized blocks common in modern dressage saddles. The undersides of the panels appear smooth and even, suggesting the flocking has been well-cared for over the decades.

I have completed a visual assessment of this Crosby Prix St. George Dressage Saddle, dating back to the late 1980s. From my examination, the saddle appears to be an authentic Miller’s-era Crosby, indicated by the signature gold-tone maker’s nails and the specific two-tone Havana/Black grain leather configuration unique to this period. The condition is remarkably well-preserved; the fine-grained leather retains a healthy patina with minimal crazing, suggesting consistent conditioning. The presence of included stirrup leathers and Fillis irons adds immediate utility value. The market for vintage English saddles is currently niche. While Crosby was once the gold standard for 'close-contact' feel, modern dressage trends have shifted toward large thigh blocks and adjustable gullets, which this model lacks. However, there is a steady demand among traditionalists, equitation riders, and 'pony club' parents seeking high-quality craftsmanship at an entry-level price point. Comparables for this model in similar 'show-ready' condition typically sell between $400 and $700, whereas those with dry-rotted billets or flattened flocking struggle to clear $250. Final valuation is limited by the digital format of this inspection. A physical examination is required to verify the integrity of the tree (ensuring no hairline fractures) and the internal wool flocking. The safety of the stirrup bars and the 'give' of the leather billets cannot be definitively confirmed from photographs alone. I recommend a professional saddle fitter inspect the tree for symmetry and sound structural response before use in a high-impact environment. Provenance documentation or a serial number stamp (usually found on the under-flap) would further solidify its production year.