AI Appraisal Estimate

This is a 2025 Panini Score football trading card featuring Stanford Wide Receiver Elic Ayomanor. This specific version is a custom or limited-run 'Jack-o'-Lantern' parallel, characterized by a bright orange border decorated with repeating black pumpkin graphics. The card prominently features the '2025 Rookie' designation and a 'RC' (Rookie Card) logo set within a white spiderweb graphic in the top corners. Ayomanor is depicted in full motion wearing his white Stanford jersey with number 13, holding a Nike football. In the bottom right corner, a Tennessee Titans helmet logo indicates his professional team affiliation or draft projection. The card is printed on standard cardstock and is currently protected within a clear plastic penny sleeve. The condition appears to be near-mint, though accurate grading would require physical inspection for corner sharpness and surface scratching. The manufacturing details include the Score brand logo in the upper right. This set is known for its college-uniformed rookie subsets, and the Halloween motif suggests a seasonal-specific retail release or a themed set variation. The craftsmanship shows clean printing registration and vibrant color saturation, typical of modern high-volume sports card production.

I have virtually examined this 2025 Score Elic Ayomanor Rookie Card in the seasonal 'Jack-o'-Lantern' parallel. Based on high-resolution imagery, the item displays typical characteristics of a modern retail parallel: vibrant orange ink saturation, clean registration on the spiderweb graphic, and centered 'RC' logos. The card exhibits 'Near-Mint' (NM) characteristics, with edges appearing sharp under magnification, though minor surface dimpling—common in Score's cardstock—cannot be ruled out without a physical loupe inspection. Market conditions for modern unlicensed or semi-licensed collegiate subsets like Score remain volatile. As a 2025 release, Ayomanor's value is currently driven by speculation regarding his transition to the Tennessee Titans. The Halloween parallel is a niche thematic variant; while more rare than base cards, it lacks the prestige of low-numbered parallels (e.g., /10 or /25). Recent sales of similar ‘holiday’ parallels for late-round or rookie receivers fluctuate between $10 and $40 depending on player hype. Limitations of this appraisal include the inability to verify the card's thickness, surface texture, and the presence of micro-creasing that may only be visible under directed light. A definitive valuation would require physical inspection to confirm the integrity of the corners and surface gloss. For full authentication, I would recommend submitting this to a third-party grader such as PSA or BGS to verify it has not been trimmed and to provide a definitive numerical grade, which would serve as the primary catalyst for any future appreciation in value.