AI Appraisal Estimate

This is an original circular lithograph campaign button from the presidential era of Franklin D. Roosevelt, likely dating to his 1940 or 1944 re-election campaigns. The pin features a classic tri-color horizontal design with a red top band, a cream/white center band, and a dark blue bottom band. The text is printed in a sans-serif typeface, reading 'I Want' in the red section, 'ROOSEVELT' in large bold letters across the center, and 'Again' in the blue section. Physically, the item is a standard small-diameter celluloid or lithographed tin button with a metal pin-back assembly. Small maker's marks are visible along the bottom edge curl, identifying the manufacturer as 'Bastian Bros. Co. Rochester, N.Y.', a well-known producer of political memorabilia. Condition-wise, the button shows significant signs of age-related wear including surface yellowing of the central white band, minor scratching, and visible foxing or oxidation spots. There is also evident rust or corrosion on the metal pin protruding from the bottom and along the edges. Such pieces are quintessential examples of mid-20th-century American political ephemera, representing a pivotal moment in U.S. history.

I have conducted a visual examination of the Franklin D. Roosevelt 'I Want Roosevelt Again' campaign button. This specific design and the 'Bastian Bros. Co.' litho-curl mark are hallmarks of authentic 1940-1944 campaign ephemera. While the design is iconic, this particular variant was produced in massive quantities, making it a common find in the Americana market. The condition of this specimen is Fair to Good. I observe significant oxidation (foxing) on the face and heavy rust on the reverse pin assembly. The central cream band has suffered from UV yellowing, which detracts from the display quality. Currently, the market for FDR-era lithographs is saturated; high-grade examples (Near Mint) typically sell for $40-$60, but the structural degradation and surface corrosion on this piece significantly suppress its value. Most collectors would view this as an entry-level filler piece rather than an investment-grade specimen. Please note that this appraisal is based on photographic evidence. A full authentication would require a physical inspection to confirm the lithographic ink texture and verify that the rust has not compromised the structural integrity of the metal curl. I would also look for any signs of modern reproduction 'flash' lines on the reverse. No scientific testing is required for an item of this value, though provenance from a known political collection could provide a nominal boost to its historical interest.