AI Appraisal Estimate

This item is a single right-foot football cleat manufactured by Phenom, featuring a high-performance design with a vibrant red and black color scheme. The cleat is constructed with a synthetic upper, featuring a gradient honeycomb mesh pattern near the ankle and a smooth red toe box. It is uniquely decorated with graphic illustrations of the character Shadow the Hedgehog from the Sonic series, positioned on the outer lateral side. A significant value-adding feature is the hand-signed autograph in black ink across the toe box, attributed to NFL quarterback Michael Penix Jr., including his jersey number '#9'. The signature appears bold and clear against the red material. The cleat includes flat black and white patterned laces and a red pull tab on the tongue printed with 'PHENOM SPEED'. The item appears to be in new, unworn condition, evidenced by the original 'PHENOM' hangtag still attached and a protective plastic film wrap covering the front half of the shoe to preserve the signature and material. The stitching and bonded overlays indicate high-quality modern athletic craftsmanship and customized aesthetic modifications intended for the collector market.

I have conducted a visual examination of this Michael Penix Jr. signed custom Phenom cleat. The item exhibits excellent condition; the synthetic upper, 'Shadow the Hedgehog' graphics, and structural integrity appear 'as-new.' The signature, rendered in black ink on the toe box, is bold and clear, featuring his distinctive '#9' inscription. Market demand for Penix Jr. memorabilia is currently high following his high-draft status and collegiate success at Washington. Custom-themed cleats (Sonic/Shadow) represent a niche '1-of-1' or limited-batch crossover market that appeals to both sports collectors and pop-culture enthusiasts, often commanding a premium over standard equipment. Comparables for signed cleats from top-tier rookie quarterbacks typically range from $300 to $800 depending on the uniqueness of the design. The specific use of the Phenom brand and the protective film wrap suggest this was a curated promotional or limited-release item, adding to its rarity. Important Limitations: This appraisal is based solely on digital images. While the signature characteristics align with known Penix Jr. exemplars, I cannot definitively verify ink depth, pressure, or authenticity without a physical inspection or a certificate from a reputable third-party authenticator (JSA, PSA/DNA, or Beckett). A full authentication would require examining the ink under magnification for signs of 'slow-signing' or printing. Provenance documentation, such as proof of the signing event or matching holograms, is necessary for this item to reach the high end of the valuation range. Verification of the 'Phenom' tag's batch number would further confirm its origin.