AI Appraisal Estimate

This is a modern sports trading card featuring an image of Quinshon Judkins in a Cleveland Browns uniform, likely from the Panini Mosaic football series. The card features a 'Green Prizm' parallel background with a distinctive holographic mosaic pattern that refracts green light and gold/silver sparkles. Notable features include the 'RC' (Rookie Card) shield in the top left and the Mosaic 'M' logo in the top right. A significant and highly visible manufacturing error or 'misprint' is present: while the image and top text field identify Quinshon Judkins, the bottom nameplate identifies 'Randy Gradishar.' The card is housed in a clear protective plastic top-loader, which obscures fine surface details, but the edges and corners appear sharp based on visible areas. This specific type of naming error, where one player's photo is paired with another's nameplate, is a rare quality control lapse that can make the card a curiosity for specialized error collectors. The construction uses a thick cardstock with a chromium-style finish and a refractive foil overlay characteristic of high-end modern sportscards. The centering appears slightly heavy toward the right side. No visible scratches or clouding are apparent through the protector.

I have carefully examined the Panini Mosaic Green Prizm featuring Quinshon Judkins. This item presents a significant manufacturing error where the bottom nameplate identifies Denver Broncos legend Randy Gradishar instead of Judkins. Visually, the card displays sharp corners and no obvious surface indentations, though the centering is slightly biased toward the right border. This 'wrong name' error is a documented occurrence in recent Panini Mosaic releases, suggesting authenticity relative to known production lapses. Market demand for modern errors is niche. While 'correct' Green Prizm parallels for a rookie like Judkins typically trade in the $5–$15 range, the error adds a novelty premium. Collectors of 'error cards' or Randy Gradishar completists may drive the price toward the upper end of the estimate, though the lack of a professional grade (PSA/BGS) limits its maximum ceiling. Unlike vintage 'corrected' errors, modern uncorrected errors often have higher supply than anticipated, which can stabilize prices quickly. My assessment is limited by the digital nature of this examination. Without a physical inspection, I cannot verify the integrity of the chromium surface under magnification to check for 'spidering' or micro-scratches hidden by the top-loader. A full authentication would require examining the card under UV light to verify reactive foil patterns and using a high-resolution scanning tool to confirm the halftone printing dots consistent with Panini’s factory process. Direct physical handling would also be needed to confirm cardstock thickness and edge smoothness.