AI Appraisal Estimate

This is a modern sports trading card featuring quarterback Tyler Shough. The card is a 'Phenoms' insert from the 2021 Panini Donruss football collection. It follows the standard 2.5 by 3.5-inch trading card dimensions but has an increased thickness to accommodate a player-worn memorabilia swatch. The design features a white and grey color palette with gold foil accents and the 'Rated Rookie' logo in the top left corner. A notable feature is the vertically oriented 'PHENOM' text on the right side. The card includes a rectangular cutout on the left containing a dark, textured fabric swatch, presumably from a college-worn jersey (Oregon or Texas Tech). Shough is depicted in a drop-back passing pose wearing a black and gold uniform. The card appears to be in excellent condition, housed within a clear protective top-loader and resting on a display stand. The centering appears slightly heavy toward the left, and the edges look crisp without visible chipping. These cards are highly manufactured with modern printing techniques including gloss coating and metallic foil stamping, primarily aimed at the high-end secondary collector market.

I have conducted a visual examination of the 2021 Panini Donruss Phenoms Tyler Shough jersey rookie card. The card features a player-worn memorabilia swatch and the iconic 'Rated Rookie' branding. Based on the provided imagery, the card appears to be in Near-Mint to Mint condition (NM-MT 8). The gold foil stamping remains vibrant, and the surface shows no evidence of the common 'dimpling' associated with thick jersey cards. The edges are crisp, though the centering is slightly biased toward the left. As an unnumbered insert in a high-volume product, this card is relatively common. The current market for Tyler Shough is characterized by low demand primarily due to his collegiate journeyman status and lack of significant NFL momentum, which limits the value to 'speculative' levels. Comparables for similar non-auto jersey inserts from this set typically settle in the single-digit to low double-digit range. Critically, I cannot verify the authenticity of the memorabilia swatch or the chemical composition of the gloss coating from a digital image. A physical inspection would be required to rule out 'patch swapping' or surface 'doctoring.' To reach a definitive authentication, the card should be submitted to a third-party grader like PSA or BGS, which would use magnification and UV light to confirm structural integrity and provide a numerical grade that could potentially increase liquidity.