AI Appraisal Estimate

This is a 2023 Panini Score football trading card featuring Jeffery Simmons, a Defensive Tackle (DT) for the Tennessee Titans. The card is a limited-run seasonal 'Pumpkin' parallel, characterized by its vibrant orange border adorned with a repeat pattern of black jack-o'-lantern illustrations. The central graphic shows Simmons in his home dark blue Titans jersey (number 98) with a red protective sleeve on his left arm, set against a stadium background. The design also features festive white spiderweb motifs in the upper corners of the inner green frame. The 'Score' brand logo is visible in the top right, while the Titans logo helmet is positioned in the bottom left corner. The card is composed of standard glossy cardstock and is currently protected within a clear soft plastic penny sleeve and likely a rigid top-loader. The centering appears slightly heavy toward the bottom and left edges of the internal frame. The corners and edges appear crisp without visible chipping or whitening, although a comprehensive grade would require inspection outside of the protective sleeve. This specific 'Halloween' variant is typically found in retail-exclusive gravity feeds or blaster boxes, making it a popular sub-set among team and player collectors.

I have examined the 2023 Panini Score Jeffery Simmons Pumpkin parallel (#291) via high-resolution imagery. This seasonal retail-exclusive variant features the distinct 'jack-o'-lantern' orange border. The card presents in 'Near Mint-Mint' condition; corners appear sharp with no visible blunting, and edges show no significant chipping. However, internal framing reveals a slight bias toward the bottom-left, common in mass-produced Panini Score sets. Authenticity is supported by the correct application of the glossy finish and the crispness of the 'Score' typography, though a physical surface inspection is required to check for 'spider-web' micro-scratches or indentations often found on glossy stock. Market demand for Jeffery Simmons—while a premier defensive talent—follows the standard trend for defensive players in modern collecting, trailing significantly behind quarterbacks and skill positions. This Pumpkin parallel is a non-numbered 'chase' card found in retail formats. Comparable sales for similar defensive 'Pumpkin' parallels from the 2023 set typically fluctuate between $2 and $10 depending on the player and shipping costs. Its status as a raw (un-graded) base-brand parallel limits its high-end ceiling. Limitations: This appraisal is based solely on digital images. A definitive guarantee of authenticity and a precise numerical grade would require an in-person loupe examination for surface bubbles or trimming and a pixel-level analysis of the printing patterns to rule out high-quality reprints. For full authentication, I recommend submitting the card to a third-party grading service (PSA, BGS, or SGC) to verify mechanical integrity and thickness.