Photo and notes provided by the user — not generated by AI
Submitted photo · May 27, 2026
User's notes
No additional notes provided.
AI analysis below
AI appraisal
AI analysis & estimate
AI-Generated · Verify before acting
Everything below is generated by AI for informational purposes only. AI can make mistakes — the AI may misidentify items or misattribute them (artist, maker, brand, designer, origin, era). This is not an official valuation and should not be used for insurance, sale, tax, estate, legal, or lending purposes — or any decision requiring a certified appraisal. It is not an authoritative claim about any person, brand, or rights holder — do not share or rely on it as a factual statement about a third party. Always consult qualified professionals before making financial decisions.
I have thoroughly examined the provided image of the 2015 Panini USA Baseball 'Team Signatures' Jordan Butler card (18U-JB, #179/499).
**Condition & Authenticity:** Based on the visual evidence, the card appears to be in excellent condition. The corners are sharp, edges clean, and there are no visible creases, surface scratches, or significant wear. This suggests good handling and storage. The numbering 179/499 is clearly visible, confirming its limited status. The 'USA Baseball' and 'PANINI' logos, along with the text 'The autograph is guaranteed by Panini America, Inc.', contribute to its perceived authenticity as a legitimate Panini product. However, it's crucial to note that no autograph is visible on this side of the card, and this might be a base card from a set that also included signed versions. My authenticity assessment is based solely on the visual fidelity of the card to known Panini releases of this era. A full authenticity verification would require physical inspection to confirm card stock, print quality, and UV features, and ideally, an accompanying certificate of authenticity (if one existed separately for this specific card, though usually, Panini’s guarantee is printed directly on the card for signed versions, which this does not explicitly show).
**Market Conditions & Comparables:** Cards for baseball prospects who do not reach the MLB, like Jordan Butler, generally have a significantly lower market demand than established stars or top prospects. While it's a limited edition, the print run of 499 is not exceedingly rare in the broader trading card market. Comparable non-autographed base cards of similar prospects from this set typically sell for minimal values, often in the single digits. The 'Team Signatures' branding implies this is part of a set where autographs are central, making a non-autographed version inherently less valuable.
**Demand & Rarity:** The rarity (limited to 499) is somewhat offset by the low demand for Jordan Butler's cards given his professional trajectory did not involve significant MLB success. Player-specific demand is the primary driver for prospect cards, and without a major league career, the collector base is small, primarily limited to team-specific or player-specific completionists.
**Factors Impacting Value:** The primary factor limiting value is the player's lack of major league prominence. The absence of an actual autograph on the card (despite being from a 'Team Signatures' set) significantly reduces its appeal compared to signed variants. Its excellent condition is a positive, but not enough to overcome the fundamental lack of demand.
**Limitations:** Without a physical examination, I cannot confirm the exact texture, weight, or detect subtle surface imperfections. Crucially, without a physical card, I cannot verify the presence or absence of an actual autograph (which is not visible in the provided image). If an autograph is present on the front (perhaps not captured), the value would change dramatically. My appraisal assumes this card does *not* feature an on-card autograph.