AI Appraisal Estimate

This is a highly collectible modern sports card featuring NFL quarterback Ryan Tannehill of the Tennessee Titans. The card is a 2022 Panini Donruss Optic series 'Press Proof' or similar parallel, specifically featuring a game-used relic. The physical construction consists of thick cardstock with a metallic 'Optichrome' finish that displays a vibrant rainbow holographic effect under light. The card features a distinct 'Gold' border, which typically signifies a short-print serialization. Notable on the left surface is the hand-stamped serial number '23/51' (or similar numbering based on the specific parallel run). A key feature is the circular die-cut window at the bottom center containing an authentic piece of a brown pebbled leather 'Game Used Ball' from a specific matchup. The right side of the card is inscribed with the date '10/23/22' and the matchup 'IND VS TEN'. The card is presented in a thick rigid plastic magnetic 'One-Touch' holder and further protected by a clear poly sleeve, suggesting the owner has prioritized preservation. Condition appears excellent with sharp corners and no visible surface scratches through the plastic, though a formal professional grade is required for definitive condition assessment. The high-quality printing, foil stamping, and authentic memorabilia piece represent premium modern trading card craftsmanship.

I have virtually examined this 2022 Panini Donruss Optic Ryan Tannehill game-used memorabilia card. Based on the visual evidence, the card appears to be from the 'Rookie Phenoms' or similar memorabilia insert set within the Optic line, despite Tannehill being a veteran. The specific numbering '23/51' noted in the description identifies this as a limited parallel, likely the Bronze or Orange variant rather than the true Gold (which is usually /10) or Gold Vinyl (/1). The card features a clear, embedded piece of football leather that Panini certifies as 'Game Used,' specifically dating it to the October 23, 2022, matchup between the Colts and Titans. The condition appears Near Mint or better (NM-MT) based on the sharp corners and centering visible through the magnetic One-Touch holder. The surface retains its original gloss with no obvious creases. Market analysis indicates soft demand for Ryan Tannehill cards post-2023, as he is no longer a starting quarterback for the Titans and his hobby relevance has declined significantly. Comparables for non-autographed veteran relics, even short-printed ones like this /51, typically trade in the low double digits. The specific game-dating adds a layer of interest for niche collectors, but does not drive massive premiums without an autograph or superstar status. While the card stock and foil stamping appear consistent with authentic Panini production, definitive authentication requires physical inspection to verify surface integrity and rule out aftermarket tampering. No scientific testing is typically required for modern cards, but an in-hand loupe review would confirm edge sharpness.