AI Appraisal Estimate

This is a 2025 Score Phil Mafah trading card featuring the Clemson Tigers running back. The card is a standard-sized sports collectible printed on cardstock with a matte finish. The design features a dark navy blue border with white inner framing. At the top left, the text '2025 ROOKIE' is visible, with the 'SCORE' brand logo in the top right. A stylized 'RC' Rookie Card shield is positioned on the right side of the main action photograph. The photo depicts Mafah in his orange and white Clemson uniform carrying a football. The bottom of the card contains a nameplate identifying 'PHIL MAFAH' and his position 'RUNNING BACK'. A graphic of a football helmet with a star is located in the bottom right corner of the image frame. The card is currently housed in a clear protective polypropylene sleeve (penny sleeve) and displayed on a small wooden easel. This modern card represents a 'pre-rookie' or early release for the 2025 season. The corners appear sharp and the edges clean, indicating a high-grade condition with no visible surface scratches or creases. The centering appears slightly heavy to the right, which is a common manufacturing characteristic of the Score set.

I have examined current high-resolution imagery regarding the 2025 Score Phil Mafah rookie card. The item is in 'Raw' condition, appearing to be Near Mint-Mint (NM-MT 8+) at first glance. The surface displays original gloss, and the corners show sharp points without visible whitening. However, technical centering is noted as slightly heavy toward the right-side border, which is a frequent production variance in the Score brand. As an early 'pre-rookie' release for the upcoming draft class, this card represents the first professional trading card appearance for the Clemson standout. Market conditions for Score are generally characterized by high volume and lower scarcity compared to premium brands like Prizm or National Treasures. Comparable sales for non-numbered, base cards of lead running back prospects in this set typically cluster between $3 and $15 during the initial hype cycle of the release. The value is currently driven by speculative interest in Mafah’s NFL Draft stock; a high draft position would provide a modest ceiling, while the high print run of base Score cards limits long-term rarity. Authenticity cannot be definitively verified via imagery alone. A physical inspection would be required to verify cardstock thickness, ink sublimation patterns under 10x magnification, and the presence of UV-protective coating. To transition this item from its current speculative value to a verified collectible, I recommend professional grading (PSA or SGC) to solidify the condition grade and guarantee authenticity. My appraisal assumes the card is a genuine Panini product and not a high-quality reproduction.