AI Appraisal Estimate

This is a 2009 Donruss Elite football trading card featuring William Beatty, an offensive tackle from the University of Connecticut, who was drafted by the New York Giants. The card is a standard 2.5 by 3.5-inch rectangular trading card made of cardstock with a high-gloss, premium finish. The design features a central action photograph of Beatty in his blue and white UConn Huskies collegiate uniform, framed by a modern, architectural grey and silver geometric border. In the upper center, the 'Donruss Elite 2009' logo is prominently displayed, flanked by the word 'ROOKIE' in a sans-serif font. The bottom of the card lists his professional team as 'GIANTS' above his name, 'WILLIAM BEATTY', which is printed in a stylized white font. The background behind the player has a reflective, radial linear pattern that creates a sense of motion. The card is currently housed in a clear protective plastic sleeve (penny sleeve). Regarding condition, the card appears well-centered with sharp corners and clean edges visible through the sleeve, with no obvious surface scratches or creases, suggesting it has been well-maintained. This card is part of a series known for its high-end production quality and was manufactured by Panini (under the Donruss brand).

I have examined the digital image of the 2009 Donruss Elite William Beatty rookie card #153. My assessment indicates a card in Near Mint to Mint condition (NM-MT 8 or better), exhibiting sharp corners, solid centering, and the characteristic high-gloss finish associated with the Donruss Elite product line. While the card appears physically well-preserved within its protective sleeve, its market value is heavily constrained by the position played by the athlete and the subsequent career trajectory. William Beatty had a solid professional career as an offensive tackle, notably winning Super Bowl XLVI with the Giants; however, offensive linemen typically see very limited demand in the secondary trading card market compared to 'skill' positions like quarterbacks or wide receivers. Market comparables for base rookie cards from this era and position typically range between $1 and $5. Rarity is relatively low for base versions of this set, which were produced in high volumes. The primary value drivers here are the brand recognition of Donruss Elite and the regional interest from UConn or Giants completionist collectors. Please note: This appraisal is based solely on digital images. Without an in-person examination, I cannot verify the integrity of the surface for micro-scratches or identify potential card trimming. Full authentication would require physical inspection under 10x magnification to check for edge wear and surface consistency. To achieve maximum value or verify authenticity, a professional third-party grading service (such as PSA, BGS, or SGC) would need to examine the card directly to confirm it has not been altered or recolored.