AI Appraisal Estimate

This is a 2025 collegiate-level football trading card from the Score brand, featuring James Pearce Jr., a defensive end from the University of Tennessee. The card is a specialty 'Halloween' or 'Jack-O'-Lantern' parallel, distinguished by a vibrant orange border decorated with repeating black pumpkin icons. The central image shows Pearce Jr. in his Tennessee Volunteers uniform, including the iconic white helmet with single orange stripe and number 27. The layout features decorative spiderwebs in the upper corners and a prominent 'RC' (Rookie Card) shield. A notable design element at the bottom right is an NFL Atlanta Falcons helmet icon, indicating his professional team association. The card utilizes a vertical orientation with a matte-to-semi-gloss finish on standard cardstock. Condition appears favorable as it is currently housed in a clear protective pennysleeve and top-loader, which helps preserve the corners and surface from wear. The graphics are sharp with bold typography and a saturated color palette. This type of seasonal parallel is limited in production compared to base sets, making it a target for player collectors and fans of themed sports memorabilia.

I have examined the digital representation of the 2025 Score James Pearce Jr. 'Jack-O'-Lantern' parallel. This specific card represents a niche 'case-hit' or short-printed seasonal parallel, which typically carries a premium over standard base parallels due to its distinctive orange pumpkin-motif border. From this visual assessment, the card appears to be in Near-Mint to Mint (NM-MT) condition; the corners appear sharp through the top-loader, and the centering is visually balanced. However, static images cannot detect surface scratches, 'snowing' on the orange borders, or subtle edge chipping common in Score's cardstock. As James Pearce Jr. is a highly touted defensive prospect, his market value is currently driven by collegiate collectors and 'projection' speculators. While 2024–25 Score releases are high-volume, these themed parallels maintain scarcity. I have based this valuation on current secondary market trends for similar defensive rookie parallels in the 'Score' seasonal product line. Limitations: This appraisal is based solely on images. Full authentication would require a hands-on examination to verify surface integrity and cardboard density. To ensure 100% authenticity and maximize value, I recommend submission to a third-party grading service like PSA or BGS, which would use magnification and ultraviolet light to confirm the absence of trimming or surface restoration. Provenance documentation from the original set packer would further solidify its chain of custody.