AI Appraisal Estimate

This is a rare and historically significant 1860 political campaign token representing the Republican ticket of Abraham Lincoln and Hannibal Hamlin. This specific type is known as a 'Union of the States' ferrotype, featuring a circular brass frame with a raised, decorative beaded edge. Centered within the frame is a black-and-white ferrotype (tintype) portrait of a beardless Abraham Lincoln. The surrounding metal frame is embossed with the legends 'ABRAHAM LINCOLN' and 'UNION OF THE STATES' along with the date '1860'. The reverse (not visible but historical context confirms) typically features a matching ferrotype portrait of Vice Presidential candidate Hannibal Hamlin. Physically, the token measures approximately 25mm to 30mm in diameter. The construction consists of thin sheet brass crimped around two glass-covered tintype photographs. The condition shows significant signs of age and handled wear; the metal exhibits a dark charcoal-colored patina with some surface oxidation and minor denting at the top near the suspension hole. The ferrotype image appears somewhat darkened or slightly out of focus, which is common for photos of this era, though the subject remains clearly identifiable. A light blue and white striped fabric ribbon is attached through a hole at the top, likely a contemporary or early addition for wearing during a political rally. These pieces represent a high level of mid-19th-century campaign craftsmanship and are highly sought after by numismatic and political memorabilia collectors.

Based on my examination of the 1860 'Union of the States' ferrotype, I have assessed this piece as a genuine DeWitt AL-1860-50 (or similar variant) representative of the first Lincoln campaign. The circular brass frame retains its structural integrity despite a heavy charcoal patina and minor oxidation. While the portrait image shows the expected 'bubbling' or emulsion darkening common in mid-19th-century tintypes, Lincoln’s beardless likeness remains distinct. The presence of the original suspension hole and the addition of a contemporary ribbon significantly enhances its 'as-worn' historical character. Market demand for 1860 Lincolniana remains at a colonial-level premium. Comparable sales of 25mm-30mm ferrotypes in similar 'Good' to 'Fine' condition range from $2,000 to $4,500, with higher premiums for those with clear, non-degraded portraits. The Hamlin reverse is essential for the higher end of this valuation. While the surface oxidation and slight denting slightly temper the price, the 'Union of the States' legend is a highly coveted political sentiment that drives buyer interest among specialized numismatists. Note on authenticity: While the crimping technique and die-striking appear consistent with period manufacturing, this appraisal is based on photographic evidence. A final verification would require a physical inspection to confirm the weight of the metal, the substrate of the photographs, and the absence of modern adhesive or replica photographic paper. The ribbon’s fabric age should be verified under UV light to ensure it is not a later polyester replacement. I recommend secondary authentication through a specialized numismatic service (e.g., NGC/PCGS) for an official grade to maximize market liquidity.