AI Appraisal Estimate

This is a 2023 Panini Score football trading card featuring Philadelphia Eagles wide receiver DeVonta Smith. The card is a seasonal 'Pumpkin' parallel, distinguished by a vibrant orange border decorated with repeating Jack-o'-lantern illustrations. The central image shows Smith in his mid-stride during a game, wearing the Eagles' deep teal home jersey and helmet. Additional thematic graphics include spider webs in the upper corners of the inner green frame. The Panini 'Score' logo is visible in the top right, while a graphic of an Eagles helmet is positioned in the lower left. The card is constructed of standard glossy cardstock and is currently protected within a clear plastic penny sleeve. In terms of condition, the corners appear sharp and the surface shows no obvious scratches or creases, though centering appears slightly biased toward the top. This specific parallel was released as part of Panini's retail-exclusive seasonal sets, making it a more collectible, time-limited variant compared to the base version of the card.

I have virtually examined this 2023 Panini Score DeVonta Smith Pumpkin Parallel #156. The card features the 'Pumpkin' retail-exclusive pattern, characterized by the orange jack-o'-lantern holiday motif. My physical assessment of the provided image reveals a card in Near Mint condition; the corners appear sharp with no visible whitening, and the glossy surface lacks obvious scuffs. I do note a minor centering bias toward the top edge, which is common for the Score production line but may prevent a 'Gem Mint' grade from professional services. Market-wise, the Pumpkin parallel is a time-limited retail variant. While rarer than the base card, it remains a high-population insert. Current market comparables for modern non-numbered parallels of star receivers like DeVonta Smith typically fluctuate in the single-digit range. Demand is driven primarily by Philadelphia Eagles team collectors and 'master set' builders. Values for modern trading cards are highly volatile and heavily dependent on professional grading. A 'Raw' (unauthenticated) version holds modest value, whereas a PSA 10 specimen could command a premium. Limitations: This appraisal is based solely on a high-resolution image provided by the client. I cannot definitively verify cardstock thickness, surface indentation, or authenticity of the gloss feel without a physical inspection. For full authentication, an in-person examination under 10x magnification or submission to a third-party grading service (PSA, BGS, or SGC) is required to rule out sophisticated reprints and confirm the card’s structural integrity.