AI Appraisal Estimate

This is a specialized trading card featuring Cleveland Browns running back Nick Chubb, produced by Panini under the Score brand for the 2023 season. This specific card is a limited-run seasonal parallel, easily identified by the vibrant orange border intricately patterned with Jack-O-Lantern pumpkin graphics. The card design incorporates unique Halloween-themed elements, including white spiderwebs in the upper corners of the central image frame. Nick Chubb is depicted in high-action, wearing the Browns' white and orange road uniform. The card measures approximately 2.5 by 3.5 inches and is constructed from standard cardstock with a glossy finish. Notable branding include the modern 'Score' logo in the top right and a stylized Browns helmet in the bottom left. The card appears to be in Excellent to Near-Mint condition, housed in a protective clear plastic sleeve and displayed on a wooden stand. The centering appears well-balanced, and the corners, visible through the sleeve, look sharp with no immediate signs of fraying or whitening. This specific 'Pumpkin' or 'Jack-O-Lantern' parallel is a retail-exclusive variant, often found in 'Halloween' themed packs, making it a distinct collectible compared to the standard base set. The craftsmanship is typical of modern Panini sports cards, featuring high-resolution photography and crisp graphic printing.

I have examined the 2023 Panini Score Nick Chubb 'Jack-O-Lantern' parallel #112. The card displays excellent eye appeal with sharp corners and balanced centering. The orange pumpkin-patterned borders are vibrant, and the surface, viewed through a protective sleeve, appears free of significant scratches or dimples. Based on visual inspection, I would categorize this in Near-Mint (NM) to Mint condition. This specific parallel is a retail-exclusive 'seasonal' insert released in Panini’s Halloween-themed products. While visually striking, it is not a 'short-print' (SP) or numbered card, meaning it was produced in relatively high volumes compared to hobby-exclusive parallels. Nick Chubb remains a highly respected figure in the hobby, though the current market for non-autographed, non-rookie base parallels in the Score brand is relatively soft. Recent comparable sales for similar 2023 Score Halloween parallels generally fall in the single-to-low-double-digit range. Verification of authenticity from a digital image is limited. While the printing patterns and 'Score' holographic elements appear consistent with Panini’s 2023 production standards, I cannot verify the stock's weight, the feel of the gloss, or look for micro-printing defects common in counterfeits. A full professional authentication would require an in-person examination using a 10x jeweler’s loupe to inspect the halftone dot patterns and edge consistency. Additionally, submitting the card to a third-party grading service like PSA or BGS would be necessary to confirm the grade I have estimated here, which would be the primary driver for any future increase in market value.