AI Appraisal Estimate

This item is a 1930 United States five-cent piece, commonly known as a Buffalo Nickel or Indian Head Nickel, designed by James Earle Fraser. The coin is composed of 75% copper and 25% nickel, featuring the iconic profile of a Native American on the obverse and an American bison on the reverse (though the reverse is not visible in this image). This specific specimen exhibits a 'Dark Tone,' as noted on the 2x2 cardboard coin flip, which indicates a heavy natural patina or environmental oxidation that has darkened the original silver-grey luster of the nickel surface. Physically, the coin measures approximately 21.2mm in diameter with a plain edge. On the obverse, the Native American profile shows moderate wear; while the basic features are clear, there is smoothing visible on the hair braids and the cheekbone. The date '1930' is legible at the lower left, and the word 'LIBERTY' is visible at the upper right. The cardboard holder features handwritten notations including '1930', 'VF+' (indicating a grade of Very Fine plus), 'Dark Tone', and a '8' which likely refers to a price or inventory number. The condition suggests circulated use with softened high-point details but no major gouges or scratches visible through the protective Mylar window. The craftsmanship represents the early 20th-century American realistic style of coinage which moved away from classical allegories toward more rugged, nationalist imagery.

I have examined the 1930 Buffalo Nickel, currently housed in a 2x2 cardboard holder. The coin displays characteristics consistent with a 'Very Fine' (VF) grade, showing moderate wear on the high points of the Native American's hair and cheekbone, while maintaining a fully legible date and 'LIBERTY' inscription. The 'Dark Tone' noted on the holder indicates significant environmental oxidation; while many collectors prefer original mint luster, some appreciate this deep patina. Based on the 1930 Philadelphia minting of over 22 million units, this is a common-date issue in the series. Comparable market sales for circulated 1930 nickels in VF condition typically fall within the $4 to $7 range. While the seller's notes mention '1926,' the physical specimen clearly shows a 1930 date. The '8' notation likely represents a Previous retail price. Limitations: This appraisal is based on photographic evidence. I cannot verify the coin's weight, exact metallic composition, or the presence of hidden edge defects or cleaning marks obscured by the patina or Mylar window. Full authentication would require a physical inspection to rule out contemporary counterfeits and a more precise grading assessment using a 10x loupe. For high-value certainty, submission to a third-party grading service like PCGS or NGC would be necessary, though the current market value of this specific coin does not justify the associated grading fees.