Inscribed Legal Reference Book (Carswell Prize, 1930) Appraisal
Category: Book
Description
This item is the front endpaper of an old law book, likely bound in a dark material, possibly leather or a similar durable fabric, given its age and purpose. The visible 'endpaper' appears to be a heavy, off-white or light cream-colored paper, showing some natural discoloration and minor foxing typical of aged paper. The most prominent feature is the handwritten inscription in black ink, detailing an academic prize awarded in 1930. The handwriting is clear, legible script, exhibiting a consistent style, suggesting it was written by the same individual. The inscription specifies that the book was 'Won by Joseph J. Powell BA LLB, as part of his share in the Carswell Prize – graduating class in law 1930.' It further elaborates on the Carswell Prize of $50, divided between Kenneth S. Smith (1st in class - $30 worth of law books) and Joseph J. Powell (2nd in class - $20 worth of law books). The inscription also lists 'Carswell Prize Law Books' as 'Bowstead on Agency,' 'Salmond on Torts,' and 'Palmer on Company Law.' Below this, the signature 'Joseph J. Powell' is visible, along with his address 'General Trust Building, Halifax, N.S.' The paper shows minor creasing along the spine edge where it meets the book's binding, and some slight waviness, indicating potential humidity exposure over time. There are no significant tears or repairs visible, and the overall condition of the inscribed page is good, maintaining its historical integrity. The dedication provides a clear historical context, associating the book with early 20th-century legal education and a specific recipient, making it a unique, personalized artifact.
Appraisal Report
Upon examining the provided image and information regarding this Inscribed Legal Reference Book (Carswell Prize, 1930), I assess its condition as good. The endpaper shows typical signs of age, including discoloration and minor foxing, but no significant tears or repairs that would substantially detract from its value. The inscription itself is clear, legible, and appears to be genuinely penned in 1930, signed by Joseph J. Powell. The details of the Carswell Prize and the listed legal texts add significant historical and biographical context. From images alone, however, I cannot definitively authenticate the ink or paper beyond visual consistency. A physical examination would be necessary to verify the age and composition of the paper and ink through micro-analysis or spectral imaging. Furthermore, provenance documentation linking Joseph J. Powell to this specific book, such as family records or university archives, would strengthen its authenticity and historical narrative. Dema nd for such an item is niche, primarily appealing to collectors of legal history, university memorabilia related to Dalhousie University (assuming that's the institution of the Carswell Prize), or those with a personal connection to Joseph J. Powell or Kenneth S. Smith. While the book itself, likely a standard legal text, might have modest value, the unique inscription transforms it into a personalized artifact. Comparables are scarce, as each inscribed prize book from this era is unique. Its value derives from its historical narrative rather than its intrinsic worth as a legal volume. The unique story of a law school prize winner from 1930 adds a layer of collectible interest, making it more significant than a common used book. If the named individuals achieved notable careers, this would further enhance its value.
Appraisal Value
$100-200