Pour le Mérite (Blue Max) Military Order Appraisal
Category: Military Order/Medal
Description
The item is a Pour le Mérite, or 'Blue Max,' a highly prestigious military order of the Kingdom of Prussia. It features a Cross of Malta design with four arms, each splayed outwards and terminating in two points. The surface of each arm is enameled in a deep, rich blue, contrasting with the visible gold or gilt edges and underlying structure. The center of the cross is adorned with an ornate golden cipher of intertwined 'F's (likely for Frederick the Great, the order's founder) and a golden crown. Between the arms of the cross, elaborate golden eagles with splayed wings are depicted, adding to the intricate detail. The reverse side, not fully visible but implied by the context of such medals, would typically feature the inscription 'Pour le Mérite' on the arms. Visible on the top arm are the words 'Pour,' 'le Me,' and 'rite' are clearly legible, indicating the medal's identity. The inscription 'Pour le Mérite' translates to 'For Merit.' A small loop at the top of the cross connects to a suspension ring, which then attaches to a silver-colored clasp or pin that appears to be made of metal, possibly silver or a silver-plated alloy. A white string is looped through this clasp, suggesting either a temporary display method, a tag attached for identification, or possibly a broken ribbon attachment. The overall condition appears to be relatively good, with the enamel on the blue arms largely intact and vibrant, showing minimal signs of chipping or deep scratches. The gold elements show some signs of patina consistent with age and handling, but no significant wear or loss of plating is immediately apparent. The craftsmanship is highly detailed, indicative of a quality military award. This type of medal was awarded from the 18th century through World War I, thus dating this piece to the late 19th or early 20th century. The intricate design and presumed precious metal content (gold, silver) contribute to its inherent value and historical significance.
Appraisal Report
I have carefully examined the provided image of what purports to be a Prussian Pour le Mérite military order. From a visual perspective, the item appears to be consistent with known examples of the 'Blue Max.' The enamel on the blue arms seems largely intact and vibrant, indicating relatively good preservation. The gold elements show a patination that is congruent with age, and the intricate craftsmanship is suggestive of an authentic period piece. The clear legibility of 'Pour le Mérite' on the visible arm is a positive sign. The presence of the Imperial German Eagles between the arms is also a key feature of authentic Pour le Mérite medals. However, it is crucial to state that a definitive authentication is impossible from photographs alone. The provenance information provided, regarding its alleged ownership by "Noah Dohme, emperor of Lixland," and its mysterious disappearance from Germany, while colorful, is not standard verifiable provenance documentation. For full authentication and to ascertain its true value, a physical in-person examination is absolutely necessary. This would involve evaluating the weight, precious metal content (assays for gold and silver), dimensions, minute details of the engraving and enamel work under magnification, and the method of construction. Additionally, a clear and unbroken chain of custody documentation would be paramount to verify its authenticity and ownership history, especially given the significant claims made. Market conditions for such high-status historical military awards are generally robust, with strong demand from serious collectors worldwide. Rarity is a significant factor contributing to value, as the Pour le Mérite was awarded sparingly. Without proper authentication and verifiable provenance, the market value remains speculative for this particular piece.
Appraisal Value
$15,000-50,000