Towle Pewter Dish Appraisal
Category: Tableware
Description
The image shows a pewter dish, likely a shallow plate or bowl, exhibiting a dull, matte silver-gray color characteristic of aged pewter. The surface appears to have a mottled or textured finish, possibly due to age, handling, or manufacturing process, with visible scratches and areas of tarnish or patina. The dish is circular in shape, although the full form is not entirely visible in the close-up. A prominent circular maker's mark or stamp is impressed into the center of the dish. This mark features a central design resembling a compass rose or star within a circle, surrounded by text. Faintly discernible text around the mark includes the word "TOWLE" at the bottom and possibly "NEWBURYPORT" at the top. This indicates the piece was manufactured by Towle Silversmiths, a well-known American company, likely at their Newburyport, Massachusetts location. The stamping appears clear and relatively well-defined but is somewhat obscured by the surface wear. There are no immediately apparent cracks or significant structural damages visible, but the overall condition suggests moderate use and age. The quality of the craftsmanship, based on the visible mark, appears to be consistent with mass-produced pewter ware from a reputable manufacturer. The style period could range from the mid-20th century onwards, given the likely brand identification.
Appraisal Report
Based on my examination of the provided image, this item is a pewter dish manufactured by Towle Silversmiths of Newburyport, Massachusetts. The piece displays a prominent maker's mark, consistent with the company's known stamps. The overall condition appears fair, showing moderate surface wear, scratches, and a developing patina typical of aged, functional pewter. There are no visible cracks or major structural damages. The authenticity seems plausible given the clear 'TOWLE' mark, but a definitive verification is limited by the digital format. For full authentication, an in-person examination would be required to assess the metal's weight, feel, and the precise details of the stamp. Without physical inspection or provenance, I cannot entirely rule out the possibility of it being a reproduction. The market for mass-produced 20th-century pewter is generally modest. While Towle is a respected name, these pewter items were made in large quantities and do not command the same prices as their sterling silver counterparts or earlier period pewter. The primary value drivers are its decorative appeal and brand recognition. The visible wear and scratches, while expected, detract from its value compared to a mint-condition example.
Appraisal Value
$10 - $25