AI Appraisal Estimate

This is an oval-shaped cast metal belt buckle, likely fashioned from a silver-toned base metal alloy with a dark, oxidized patina consistent with vintage fraternal regalia. The central motif features a prominent raised Maltese or Cross Pattee, within which resides a small, inset Latin cross accented with remnants of red enamel or paint. The background of the central medallion has a textured, grid-like stippling that provides a matte contrast to the smoother raised surfaces. The buckle is framed by an ornate border consisting of decorative scrolls, acanthus leaf flourishes, and small bead-like accents at the cardinal points. Its construction appears heavy and durable, indicative of mid-20th-century craftsmanship. Condition issues include significant surface oxidation, visible green verdigris in the recessed areas (notably at the top left), and substantial wear to the red pigment of the central cross. The overall wear patterns suggest frequent use over several decades, likely dating to the early-to-mid 1900s. No maker's mark is visible from this angle, though such pieces were commonly produced by supply companies specializing in Masonic and fraternal society uniform accessories.

I have carefully examined the provided images of this Knights Templar Masonic belt buckle. The piece is a standard example of mid-20th-century fraternal regalia, likely manufactured by a specialized outfit like M.C. Lilley & Co. or a similar lodge supply house. The design elements, specifically the Cross Pattee and the inset Latin cross, are characteristic of the Commandery orders within the York Rite of Freemasonry. Technically, the buckle is a cast base metal alloy with a silver-toned plated finish. The condition is fair to good; while the structural integrity is sound, there is significant oxidation and verdigris (copper carbonate) buildup, particularly in the scrolled border. The loss of red enamel on the central cross significantly reduces the aesthetic appeal for collectors of 'mint' regalia. The market for general Masonic items is currently saturated, as many such items have entered the secondary market from estate dispersals. Comparables for non-precious metal Commandery buckles in similar condition typically sell within the $40 to $80 range. Rarity is low, as these were mass-produced for a large membership base during the 1920s-1950s. The value is primarily driven by fraternal interest rather than material scrap value. Limitations: Visual inspection via imagery cannot confirm the exact composition of the base metal or detect hidden repairs. A full authentication would require an in-person examination to check for maker's marks on the reverse and a metallurgical test to rule out sterling silver content, though the visible oxidation pattern strongly suggests a non-precious alloy.