After All Song Sheet Music Appraisal
Category: Sheet Music
Description
This item is a piece of antique sheet music titled "After All", described as a "Song". The cover features a sepia-tone portrait of a woman holding a bouquet of flowers, likely the intended performer or model for the era. The sheet music is credited to "By the writers of 'SMILES'", with lyrics by J. Will Callahan and music by Lee S. Roberts. The publisher is listed as Jerome H. Remick & Co., with locations in Detroit and New York, and the number '5' featured above the publisher name. The paper appears aged with a creamy color, indicating its vintage. There are visible condition issues including creasing, particularly a prominent vertical crease down the center, wear along the edges including small tears and nicks, and some discoloration consistent with age and handling. There is handwriting in the upper left corner that appears to be a name and address, "Mily Grace Kay / Ho. H Schiffeumayne building" which is a unique and interesting detail but may or may not be original to the publication. The quality of the printing appears standard for the period. The overall style of the illustration and typography suggests a publication date likely in the early 20th century, given the popular song reference "Smiles" which is attributed to 1917. The sheet music was a common form of entertainment and cultural representation at this time.
Appraisal Report
I have carefully examined the provided image of the "After All" sheet music. Based on the visual evidence, I can assess its authenticity and condition, and provide an estimated market value. Authenticity: The style of the illustration, typography, and publisher information (Jerome H. Remick & Co., active in the early 20th century) strongly suggests this is an authentic piece of sheet music from that era. The reference to "By the writers of 'SMILES'" dates this piece to after 1917, when "Smiles" was popular. Without physical inspection, I cannot definitively rule out a high-quality modern reproduction, but the paper aging and wear patterns appear consistent with genuine age. Condition: The condition is fair, showing significant signs of age and use. There is a prominent central vertical crease, wear and small tears along the edges, corners are softened, and there is discoloration consistent with handling and age. The handwriting in the upper corner adds character but is not original to the publication and doesn't add monetary value. Physical inspection would allow a more precise assessment of paper integrity, acid levels, and potential repairs. Market Conditions & Demand: Sheet music from this period, even from popular songs, is relatively common. Demand varies based on the specific song, artist, and condition. "After All" is not a widely recognized standard today, limiting broad collector appeal compared to more famous tunes. Condition is a primary driver of value in this market. Comparables for early 20th-century sheet music in fair condition typically range from a few dollars to low double-digits. Rarity: This particular piece of sheet music is not considered rare. Millions of copies of popular songs were printed and distributed. Limitations: This appraisal is based solely on the provided image. A physical examination is necessary to confirm paper type, assess the full extent of damage and discoloration, and definitively rule out modern reproduction through feel and potentially UV light testing. Provenance for the specific handwritten name and address could add historical interest but is unlikely to impact market value significantly unless tied to a famous individual. In conclusion, this is an authentic piece of early 20th-century sheet music in fair, used condition. Its value is primarily decorative or sentimental rather than significant as a collectible.
Appraisal Value
$5-15